How Tall is Too Tall?

Members of the city council agreed Tuesday that some of the proposed building heights in the Downtown 2030 Plan are questionable.

So they pushed back a vote on the document until they can set some firm ground rules. The design is meant to help guide growth and changes in the city's downtown area and has been applauded by city officials at prior meetings because of the extensive work that has gone into it.

"I wouldn't want to go to the proposed 60 feet height (for buildings) along Main Street,” said Councilman Paul Hinterlong, echoing sentiments he made at a previous meeting. “… I don't think 60 feet will preserve the small-town character of our downtown."

Councilman Grant Wehrli suggested setting future height regulations based on the buildings that already exist in specific parts of the downtown corridor. He said he wants any increase in structure heights to be a gradual one.

He asked that the plan be amended to include that buildings along Washington Street, between Benton and Douglas avenues, should not exceed 43 feet in height. He said those on Main Street between Benton and Franklin avenues shouldn’t be taller than 57 feet.

Although the council seemed to support those standards, members said they’d like extra time to see those heights accurately mapped out on paper.

"(The plan) is not intended to dramatically change the environment, character and culture of the downtown," said council documents. "Rather, the plan will draw upon the principals defined within the 2000 Naperville Downtown Plan to ensure that Naperville remains a vibrant, attractive and distinct place offering shopping, living and leisure-time environments."

The 2030 plan has come before the council following a 60-day public comment period during which six people weighed in, as well as a recommendation for approval from the Downtown Advisory Commission.